Renaissance: continuation or a distinct break from the Middle Ages?

Was the Renaissance a period distinct from the Middle ages or was it a continuation - the high point – of the middle Ages?I am planning to write an essay supporting that the Renaissance was a continuation of the Middle Ages, since it certainly was not a sudden, clean break from the Dark Ages. Can anyone help me with the supports that i can provide to back my side of the debate?

Similar Asks:

  • Leonardos’ Vitruvian man? Essay Question? - I have an AP European history test on the Renaissance time period tomorrow and our teacher gave us the essay questions in advance so we could study better. One of the questions is this:Examine leonardo plots the perfect man. What is the purpose of Leonardo’s Vitruvian plotting? Why is it important? Human beings were viewed
  • CAN I GET INTO USC?!?!?!? - I am currently a male junior in high school in Colorado. I know that USC (southern california) is a private school and it does not matter what state you are applying from, however it still seems that they do give somewhat of an edge to california students.USC has been my number 1 choice for many
  • Any ideas on something involving the Middle East that I could do an essay on? - I need to do a -persuasive- research essay based on something that happened in the Middle East between 1945-1995. He said he’s looking for something like “Stalin’s succesors did not carry out his plans for the U.S.S.R and therefore eventually led to the Soviet’s collapse” and then supporting point out of history to prove that
  • What is a positive effect of joining the dark side? (star wars, for an essay XD )? - my teacher assigned us a cause and effect essay and told us we could write it on anything, this being the second paper she assigned us this week & the fact i hate her, i picked positive and negative effects of joining the dark side XD And I need one more positive effect of joining
  • English essay title? - Our english teacher gave us the title “My school playground during break” as a title for an essaywould it be out of point if i write it from the point of view of a little boy who feels as if he is being bullied during break and the way he sees the play ground? User tags:was
  • After school detention tonight (uk only)? - heya…im in year 10 at all girls high school, and tonight I had after-school detention for 2 and half hrs (3.00-5.30) where i was given lines to write and also i had to write an essay on my behaviour and code of conduct etc…soooo boring and plus my hand and fingers ached from writing lots,
  • Can anyone tell me what my dream means ? - Hey guys i was just wondering what my dream means i am stressing heaps my dream is that im back at my high school it is the winter break atm im in year 8 and the first day back we get out historian essays back and i did really well the teacher says and she

User tags:

  • was the renaissance a continuation or distintive from the middle ages essay

3 Answers to “Renaissance: continuation or a distinct break from the Middle Ages?”

  1. aurigid says:

    I try to think of all of history as a continuous progression, and our attempts to compartmentalize segments of time into distinct eras is somewhat of a fallacy. I’d recommend defining “renaissance” and going from there. I don’t know if you’ve studied Jacob Burckhardt, but he wrote a book defining the Italian Renaissance with three criteria: the state as a work of art, individualism, and a renewed admiration of antiquity. All of this occurred in what has been termed the “12th century renaissance,” (with feudal magnates using national saints and hagiographies to support their own power within the state, the first autobiographies emerging, religious authors relying on ancient philosophers to debate theology, etc.) indicating that ‘The Renaissance’ a few centuries later was not actually such a sudden break from the Middle Ages as is often depicted. Check out Peter Abelard and St. Stephen of Hungary as good primary sources, for starters. In fact, you may even want to consider our inherently biased tripartite division of European history, which essentially labels Antiquity, the “Dark” or “Middle” Ages, and the Modern Era as the three major sections of what really is a continuous timeline – all it does is help to separate in our minds the much respected Classical Period from “us” in modern times with this unimaginatively named, embarrassingly uncivilized, and overall quite miscellaneous period in between.

  2. antagonisms says:

    You are correct that it WAS a continuation or a gradual development. A good way to approach this is to pick Renaissance men from early centuries as well as the usual ones from the 1400s and 1500s such as Raphael, Michelangelo, and Leonardo. If you want to stick with the Mutant Turtles motif, you could add Donatello from the 1300s.Roger Bacon from the 1200s is another. (See link below.)It is the men before 1453 who will make your case. Sorry that there aren’t many women in this group of advanced thinkers and writers. Very few women went into a life of study in the arts.

  3. constructivism says:

    It was a continuation. Art and learning had flourished throughout the Middle Ages, they were not invented in the ‘Renaissance’, as is sometimes claimed. In fact, in many ways life regressed rather than advanced during the ‘Renaissance’. Especially for the poor people, whose living conditions generally declined during this period due to the enclosure of lands which led to many peasants being deprived of their small farms and being forced to look for employment elsewhere, or being reduced to begging. And the decline in power of the medieval guilds led to a reduction in living conditions in the towns for poor people as well. Also women’s role became more restricted as many guilds that had previously allowed women members barred them. And the Reformation meant that upper-class women in Protestant countries no longer had the option of becoming nuns, which had been a respectable alternative to marriage during the medieval period.’the Dark Ages’ is a term that refers to the centuries after the fall of the Roman empire, when the former empire was conquered by barbarians of various kinds. They are known as ‘dark’ because there was not much writing at this time, so we don’t know a lot about what was happening. They do not refer to the whole of the middle ages, which were not dark at all. the medieval period had its horrors, but warfare for instance did not become any less brutal during th the Renaissance than it had been in the medieval period, nor did the judicial system become any less harsh. And the period of the witch hunts, in which thousands of people were put to death, was not (as is sometimes claimed) the medieval period, but the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries.